SANDY BACKGROUND: ISTOCKPHOTO.COM/OATAWA, STACKED STONES: ISTOCKPHOTO.COM/DANIEL CHETRONI
ATPs and clinicians who are recommending, determining and building the seating systems for wheelchair users are not starting on a symbolically level playing field. That’s just the nature of the seating and mobility calling.
Instead, seating teams must contend with a range of clinical challenges, including client histories, diagnoses and prognoses, and balance all of that with the client’s daily goals and environments.
The Asymmetrical Posture
One such wheelchair seating challenge is the asymmetrical posture — common due to the number of conditions that can cause its presentation.
“Asymmetry can be defined by the presentation of the body either not appearing to be identical on the left and right side, or an imbalance between the body halves,” said Lee Ann Hoffman, OT, MSc. Rehabilitation: Posture Management, Solutions Specialist/Seating & Positioning, Invacare Corp. “It’s a deviation from the symmetrical presentation — even-sided or equal presentation of the left and right side.”
“Clinical reasons for an asymmetry could include a pelvic obliquity, scoliosis or a leg-length discrepancy,” said Sam Hannah, ATP, Symmetric Designs. “Some of the causes can stem from a consumer trying to offload pressure, [or having] low muscle tone and/or poor seating.”
Steve Cousins, Ph.D., R&D director for Matrix Seating Ltd., said asymmetrical postures could be caused by “cerebral palsy, brain injury, multiple sclerosis, spinal muscular atrophy, muscular dystrophy, spina bifida and other disorders. [Or by] simple biomechanical issues, like using a canvas sling seat in a wheelchair so the pelvis can slip and sideways tilt, inducing a spinal curve, or slipping forward (too open a seat/back angle, no shaping to the seat/cushion) in a wheelchair seat so that the pelvis tilts posteriorly, affecting the natural spinal lordosis (which helps to protect the back from developing scoliosis). Causes related to the underlying clinical issues are abnormal muscle tension (pulling asymmetrically) and collapse under gravity due to muscle weakness.”
Kirsten Davin, OTDR/L, ATP/SMS, added that an asymmetrical posture can develop over time.
“In some cases, what was a minor asymmetry or a non-emergent diagnosis at one time may progress into a significant postural issue, and could eventually present with vital organ structure compromise,” she explained. “For example, a child who presents with minimally invasive scoliosis at age 3 may experience spinal stenosis, continued progression of scoliosis, and perhaps as a result of poor positioning or clinical progression, may experience pelvic involvement in the form of posterior pelvic tilt or pelvic obliquity, thus leading to issues of kyphosis or increased cervical or thoracic spine asymmetry.”
And the impact, Davin said, can be dire: “This now-significant postural asymmetry can easily cause respiratory impairments as a result of decreased lung volume capacity (from the compressed or flexed position of the trunk), thus preventing adequate air exchange. In addition to respiratory impairments, clients may experience decreased bowel and bladder function, decreased digestive function, or reduced visual field and/or functional performance of activities of daily living, as a result of continued progression of asymmetry.”
“Asymmetry can both be the result of instability or the cause of instability,” Hoffman said. “Consider if the individual experiences weakness due to a neurological condition — the weakness may result in an imbalance, and the body will no longer be able to maintain symmetry, against gravity. One side may collapse or seek support from the environment, resulting in instability.
“Asymmetry also has the ability to cause instability. If the individual is in contact with a non-shape conforming surface, then contact points between the individual and the supporting surface are reduced, resulting in potential peak pressure points and instability — e.g., a kypho-scoliotic spine, with a posterior asymmetric fullness (aka, rib-hump) positioned on a flat back seating system, is unstable, as the surface is not conforming or offering support. Therefore, the trunk will rotate (and roll) until it meets with a surface of the body which has less fullness to gain stability.”
“Fixed” vs. “Flexible” Asymmetries
Until fairly recently, asymmetrical postures were often described as fixed or flexible, to supposedly denote whether they could or could not be changed.
As it turns out (see below), those terms weren’t optimally precise, since even “fixed” asymmetries can be capable of change under certain circumstances.
Asymmetries: No Longer Fixed vs. Flexible
References
Bower, E. (2009) Finnie’s Handling the Young Child with Cerebral Palsy at Home (Fourth Edition), Butterworth-Heinemann, Edinburgh. ISBN 9780750688109.
Clayton S., Goldsmith L., Ellis T. (2017) 24-hour postural care: The journey so far in the UK. www.simplestuffworks. co.uk [accessed May 25, 2017].
Pope P. (2007) Severe and Complex Neurological Disability: Management of the Physical Condition. Butterworth-Heinemann Publishers.
Taktak A., Ganney P., Long D., White P. (2014) Clinical Engineering A Handbook for Clinical & Biomedical Engineers: Long, D., Chapter 19, P 285-308. www.sciencedirect.com [accessed May 5, 2017].